Structure & Tone
The story starts with a lighthearted, fitting tone for the MLP universe but takes an extremely dark turn that feels jarring given the source material. While it's okay to write darker themes, the shift from making cheese recipes to cannibalism is too extreme and doesn't align with the show's core values or target audience.
Character Consistency
Twilight's decision to exile Pinkie and Cheese feels out of character. As the Princess of Friendship who values rational thinking, she would more likely investigate the incident and seek a solution.
The extreme reaction to Rainbow Dash's allergic reaction also seems disproportionate. The MLP universe typically handles conflicts through understanding and reconciliation.
Alternative Suggestions
Consider reworking the conflict in a way that maintains the show's spirit while still creating drama:
Instead of exile and death, perhaps Cheese and Pinkie could go on a journey to find a cure for pegasus cheese allergies
The conflict could focus on Cheese learning to adapt her recipes to be inclusive of all pony types
The story could explore themes of friendship and understanding through cooking mishaps without the extreme consequences
The Ending
Rather than the current dark ending, consider a resolution that teaches valuable lessons about:
Food safety and being mindful of others' dietary needs
The importance of communication
How mistakes can lead to growth and understanding
Beginning: Pinkie Pie and Cheese Pie's Delightful Reunion
Strengths: The beginning is lighthearted and in line with My Little Pony's wholesome tone. Pinkie and Cheese bonding over creating recipes is very fitting for their cheerful and creative personalities. The cheese and milk farm near Appleloosa is a charming touch that feels well-integrated into the world of Equestria.
Opportunities: Consider grounding this section with a bit more detail about their relationship and shared excitement. This will make the later events feel even more impactful and emotionally charged.
Middle: Rainbow Dash’s Reaction and Exile
Strengths: The shift to Rainbow Dash's allergic reaction adds an element of tension and conflict. Scootaloo’s emotional reaction and Twilight's decision to exile Pinkie and Cheese raise the stakes dramatically.
Opportunities: The exile and hospital scenes feel abrupt. Developing these moments with more explanation (e.g., why Twilight feels exile is the only option) could enhance the emotional weight. This would also give more depth to Scootaloo’s grief and Twilight’s inner conflict.
End: Survival, Tragedy, and Despair
Strengths: The final act takes a surprising and deeply emotional turn, showcasing despair and survival instincts. This adds a raw intensity to the story.
Opportunities: The cannibalism subplot feels extremely out of place in the My Little Pony universe, which is generally uplifting and family-friendly. Consider reworking this section to focus on their struggles in exile without resorting to such a grim resolution. For example, they might find unexpected help or learn an important lesson about friendship and forgiveness.
No comments:
Post a Comment